Injury to brachial plexus due to birth trauma – Diagnostics – Overview of Information and Clinical Research

Diagnosing a brachial plexus birth injury requires careful clinical examination and sometimes advanced imaging tests. Early detection and accurate assessment are crucial for determining the best treatment approach and predicting recovery outcomes for affected infants.

Introduction: Who Should Undergo Diagnostics

Parents should seek medical evaluation immediately after birth if they notice that their newborn is not moving one arm or hand as much as the other. Brachial plexus birth injury can sometimes be spotted right in the delivery room, but in other cases, the signs may become apparent only in the days or weeks following birth. If you observe that your baby’s arm hangs limply, appears to be held in an unusual position, or shows weakness when you try to move it gently, these are signals that prompt medical attention is needed.^[1]

Sometimes, a brachial plexus injury may be confused with another condition called pseudoparalysis, which occurs when an infant has a broken collarbone and avoids moving the arm because of pain rather than nerve damage. Because of this possibility, doctors will carefully examine the baby to distinguish between true nerve injury and pain-related immobility. Early diagnosis is especially important because the timing of treatment can significantly affect how well the child recovers.^[7]

Healthcare professionals typically recommend that any infant showing signs of arm weakness or limited movement should be evaluated by specialists who are experienced in treating brachial plexus injuries. These specialists can include pediatric neurologists, neurosurgeons, orthopedic surgeons, and physiatrists. Early referral to a specialized brachial plexus birth injury clinic is considered essential, as it allows for regular monitoring through serial examinations and ensures that surgical intervention can be performed at the right time if the baby’s recovery proves inadequate.^[4]

⚠️ Important

Most babies with brachial plexus birth injury will fully recover within three to four months without any surgical treatment. However, those who do not show significant improvement during this period have a poorer outlook for complete recovery and may need more intensive interventions. This is why regular follow-up and monitoring are so important during the first months of life.

Diagnostic Methods for Identifying Brachial Plexus Birth Injury

Physical Examination

The first and most important step in diagnosing a brachial plexus birth injury is a thorough physical examination performed by a healthcare provider. During this examination, the doctor will carefully observe how the baby moves both arms and will look for specific signs that indicate nerve damage. One of the most telling signs is when the affected arm appears to hang limply or is held in an odd position, often described as the “waiter’s tip” position, where the arm is rotated inward toward the body and the infant cannot move it effectively.^[5]

Doctors will check the baby’s arm for paralysis, numbness, position, and grip strength on both sides to compare the affected side with the unaffected one. They will look for a full or partial lack of movement, particularly in the shoulder and elbow, and will test whether the baby has a weakened grip. The position of the arm is also revealing—it may bend toward the body or hang completely limp if the nerve injury is significant.^[2]

Another important part of the physical examination is checking the baby’s Moro reflex, which is also called the startle response. This is a normal reflex in newborns where the baby throws back their head, extends the arms and legs, and then pulls them back in when startled. In infants with brachial plexus injury, the Moro reflex will be absent or diminished on the affected side. This finding helps confirm that there is nerve damage rather than just a temporary muscle weakness.^[2]

The healthcare provider will also examine the baby’s clavicle, which is the collarbone, to check for a fracture. This is important because a broken clavicle can cause similar symptoms to a brachial plexus injury, but the underlying problem and treatment are different. If a fracture is present, the baby may need an X-ray to confirm the diagnosis and rule out pseudoparalysis.^[7]

Imaging Studies

When the physical examination suggests a brachial plexus injury, or when the healthcare team needs more detailed information about the extent and location of the nerve damage, imaging studies may be ordered. These tests help specialists understand which nerves are affected and how severely they have been injured, which in turn helps guide treatment decisions.

X-rays are often the first imaging test performed, primarily to rule out bone injuries such as a fractured clavicle or humerus that could be causing the baby’s symptoms. X-rays cannot show nerve damage directly, but they are useful for identifying bone problems that might be contributing to the baby’s lack of movement.^[2]

Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is a more advanced imaging technique that can provide detailed pictures of soft tissues, including nerves. MRI uses magnets and radio waves rather than radiation to create images of the inside of the body. For brachial plexus injuries, MRI can help doctors see the nerve roots at the spinal cord and determine whether the nerves have been torn or pulled away from the spinal cord. This information is particularly valuable when doctors are trying to decide whether surgery might be necessary.^[2]

Nerve and Muscle Function Tests

To get a clearer picture of how well the nerves and muscles are functioning, specialists may order tests that measure electrical activity. A nerve conduction study (NCS) measures how quickly electrical signals travel through a nerve. This test can help identify where along the nerve pathway the damage has occurred and how severe it is. During an NCS, small electrodes are placed on the skin over the nerve being tested, and a mild electrical pulse is sent through the nerve to see how it responds.^[2]

An electromyogram (EMG) is often performed alongside a nerve conduction study. An EMG measures the electrical activity of muscles when they are at rest and when they are contracting. This test helps doctors understand whether the muscles are receiving proper signals from the nerves. If the nerves are damaged, the muscles may show abnormal electrical patterns. Together, these tests provide valuable information about the location and severity of nerve injury.^[2]

Serial Examinations and Monitoring

Because many babies with brachial plexus birth injury recover spontaneously over time, regular follow-up examinations are an essential part of the diagnostic process. Specialists will schedule serial exams to monitor the baby’s progress and look for signs of improvement. These examinations typically begin when the baby is a few weeks old and continue at regular intervals throughout the first year of life.

During these follow-up visits, healthcare providers will assess muscle strength, range of motion, and functional abilities such as reaching, grasping, and lifting the arm. They may use standardized assessment tools to measure progress objectively. The pattern and rate of recovery observed during these serial examinations help doctors predict the final outcome and decide whether and when surgical intervention might be needed.^[4]

⚠️ Important

Certain signs during the diagnostic process may indicate a more severe injury. For example, if the baby has a droopy eyelid on the affected side, this may point to a condition called Horner’s syndrome, which is usually associated with a more serious type of nerve injury called an avulsion, where the nerve roots are torn from the spinal cord. This finding alerts doctors that the injury may require more aggressive treatment.

Diagnostics for Clinical Trial Qualification

When families consider enrolling their child in a clinical trial to test new treatments for brachial plexus birth injury, additional diagnostic assessments may be required to determine whether the child meets the study’s entry criteria. Clinical trials typically have specific inclusion and exclusion criteria that help researchers ensure they are studying a well-defined group of patients.

For brachial plexus injury trials, researchers may require baseline measurements of muscle strength, range of motion, and functional abilities using standardized assessment scales. One commonly used tool is the Active Movement Scale (AMS), which grades the baby’s ability to move different parts of the arm against gravity. This scale helps researchers measure changes in function over time and compare outcomes between different treatment groups.^[8]

Clinical trials may also require specific imaging studies to confirm the diagnosis and classify the type of nerve injury. MRI scans might be used to verify the location and extent of nerve damage. In some cases, nerve conduction studies and electromyography may be required to document the baseline electrical function of the nerves and muscles before treatment begins. These tests are then repeated at specific time points during the trial to measure whether the experimental treatment is working.

The timing of enrollment in a clinical trial is often crucial. Many trials have age restrictions, accepting only infants who are within a certain age range, such as between three and nine months old. This is because the window for nerve recovery and the potential benefits of surgical intervention are time-dependent. Researchers may also exclude children who have already undergone certain treatments or who have other medical conditions that could affect the study results.

Some clinical trials may require genetic testing or blood tests to rule out other conditions that could affect nerve development or healing. Documentation of the circumstances surrounding the birth, such as birth weight, length of labor, and whether there were complications like shoulder dystocia, may also be collected as part of the trial screening process. All of these diagnostic measures help ensure that the children enrolled in the trial are appropriate candidates for the specific treatment being studied and that the results will be scientifically valid.

Prognosis and Survival Rate

Prognosis

The outlook for babies with brachial plexus birth injury varies greatly depending on the severity and type of nerve damage. The good news is that around 70 to 80 percent of children recover fully without needing surgery. Most babies will show significant improvement within the first three to four months of life. Mild injuries where the nerve has been stretched but not torn tend to have the best outcomes, with many babies regaining both movement and feeling in the affected arm naturally.^[4]^[7]

Children who do not show full recovery by three months are more likely to have some lasting impairment, most commonly affecting the shoulder, elbow, or forearm. The type of nerve injury plays a crucial role in determining the prognosis. Stretch injuries, called neurapraxia, usually heal on their own within the first three months. Rupture injuries, where the nerve is torn but not at the spinal cord, may require surgical repair. Avulsion injuries, where the nerve roots are completely torn from the spinal cord, have the poorest prognosis and cannot be directly repaired—damaged tissue must be replaced through nerve transfer procedures.^[1]^[5]

Babies who have Horner’s syndrome—with symptoms like a droopy eyelid, smaller pupil, and reduced sweating on part of the face—typically have more severe injuries and may face greater challenges in recovery. This condition usually indicates that the sympathetic chain of nerves has been damaged, often in association with an avulsion injury. On the other hand, babies with injury limited to the upper nerves of the brachial plexus (Erb’s palsy) generally have better outcomes than those with total plexus involvement affecting all five nerves.^[1]

The prognosis also depends heavily on early intervention and appropriate treatment. Physical therapy, which typically begins when the baby is about three weeks old, plays a critical role in preventing muscle stiffness, atrophy, and joint problems such as shoulder dislocation. Children who receive consistent therapy and close monitoring tend to have better functional outcomes. For those who need surgery, the timing of the procedure is important—nerve repair or reconstruction is most effective when performed between three and nine months of age.^[1]^[7]

Long-term complications can include abnormal muscle contractions or tightening of the muscles, which may become permanent if not addressed. Some children may experience partial or total loss of function in the affected nerves, leading to ongoing arm weakness or paralysis. However, with modern treatment approaches including specialized therapy, botulinum toxin injections to balance muscle strength, and surgical options such as nerve transfers and tendon transfers, many children can achieve good functional outcomes and lead active lives.^[7]^[8]

Survival Rate

Brachial plexus birth injury is not a life-threatening condition, and survival is not typically a concern. The injury affects the nerves that control arm and hand movement and sensation but does not impact vital organs or overall life expectancy. However, in rare cases where the injury also affects the nerve to the diaphragm, breathing difficulties may occur and require medical attention. Apart from such exceptional situations, children with brachial plexus birth injury have normal life expectancy and the primary focus is on optimizing arm function and quality of life.^[1]

#1 Clinical Trials Search in Europe